CLIC Speaker Abstracts

Steven Clayman and John Heritage (Sociology, UCLA), January 19, 2001.

"Questioning Presidents: Journalistic Deference and Adversarialness in the Press Conferences of Eisenhower and Reagan."

This paper develops a new system for analyzing the questions that journalists ask of public figures in broadcast news interviews and press conferences. This system is then applied in a comparative study of the forms of questioning that characterized the press conferences of Dwight Eisenhower and Ronald Reagan. The comparison focuses on the phenomenon of adversarialness in question design. Twelve features of question design are examined that serve as indicators of four basic dimensions of adversarialness: (1) initiative, (2) bluntness, (3) assertiveness, and (4) hostility. The results reveal substantial and significant differences for 11 out of 12 indicators, all in the direction of increased adversarialness. This pattern suggests that journalists have become much less deferential and more aggressive in their treatment of the president. Possible factors contributing to this development, and its broader ramifications for the evolving relationship between journalism and government, are also discussed.